Fuji Lozada's Fieldnotes

Anthropologist at Davidson College

  • About Fuji
    • c.v.
    • Email me
    • Meet with me
  • Teaching
    • Previously Taught Classes
    • Teaching Style
      • Complex social theory can be said in plain English
      • Social/cultural theory should be relevant
      • Methodology is Important
      • Writing is a form of thinking
        • Writing a strong thesis statement
        • Making an Argument
        • Response Papers
      • Doing your own field-based research is the best way to learn about anthropology
    • Davidson in China
  • Research
    • Projects
    • Abstracts
    • My Work as a Wordle
    • Fieldnotes
      • Ghana
      • Cyberia
      • Youtube Worth Watching
  • Hack College
    • Make the digital work for you
    • Stalking your professors using Outlook
    • Read with an agenda
    • Write a research proposal
    • Outline to make research easier
    • Use theory
    • Write a literature review
    • Structure of an abstract
    • Notes on teaching and learning

Triumph of the Commons?

August 25, 2009 By Fuji

In a recent article in the New Scientist, Mark van Vugt suggests that the scenario painted by Garrett Hardin in his classic 1968 article “Tragedy of the Commons” is not really as bad as described.

Van Vugt suggests that proper management of our shared natural resources could be accomplished following the 4 i’s: information, identity, institutions, and incentives. Much of his argument hinges on the issue of trust – and as he points out, trust is built upon a sense of fairness.

One thing that van Vugt assumes, however, is that people will act rationally (whether with respect to their own well-being or for a common good) in response to greater information about environmental damages, strengthened group identity that encourages behavioral change, or added benefits to environmental stewardship. I’m not so sure.

This closely ties into our reading of Rawls’ ideas about justice. Rawls’ model of justice also relies on individuals engaged in rational, civil discourse about issues that confront a large aggregate of people like a community or nation-state. What do you think Rawls would say to van Vugt (or van Vugt would say to Rawls) about environmental social justice?

Read the full van Vugt article

Read the original Hardin “Tragedy of the Commons” article from Science magazine.

Filed Under: Anthropology, Classes, Davidson College, Environment


Eriberto P. Lozada Jr. is Associate Dean of Faculty, Professor of Anthropology and Environmental Studies, and Director of the Crosland Center for Teaching & Learning. He is a sociocultural anthropologist who has examined contemporary issues in Chinese society ranging from: religion and politics; food, popular culture and globalization; sports and society issues; and the cultural impact of science and technology. more...

Crosland Center for Teaching & Learning
Davidson College
Davidson, NC 28035 USA

office: Little Library 1005
tel. 704-894-2035
erlozada [at] davidson.edu

Make the digital work for you

Essential Tools (mostly free) (Updated, 16 March 2017) Technological literacy (something I really need to define later) is essential to getting things done in today’s mediated world. There are a lot of useful applications out there that will cut back on the tears or punched walls late in the semester. Below are some of the […]

Meet with Me

RSS shanghaiist

  • Travelers from 8 more countries will be quarantined upon arrival in Shanghai
  • Britannica Online Open Day, an Access to an Offer Letter Now

RSS anthro{dendum}

  • Why “is this fascism?” is the wrong question: a foray into the everyday life of political concepts
  • An Obituary for Alfred Kroeber (or…Can American Indians Speak?)

Men’s Lacrosse at Davidson

The Davidson College Men's Lacrosse team is a member of the Southeastern Lacrosse Conference (SELC) and competes in Division II of the Men's Collegiate Lacrosse Association.

Tweets by @thefieldworker

Copyright © 2021 Eriberto P. Lozada Jr. · Davidson College